Journal
Here are the daily questions, thoughts, provocations that get batted around in Lezlie-land: sometimes wacky, sometimes thoughtful, sometimes shamefully self-indulgent. Hey! It’s a journal!Monday, 07 September 2009 21:56
Buddhist teacher and psychotherapist Peter Carlson takes exception to the notion of the universe “conspiring” to bring lessons to individuals. This is a notion that is firmly set in New Age thinking—that there is some force “out there” pulling together exactly the circumstances needed to push us to new understandings of ourselves. People say, “Isn’t it amazing how the universe brings us exactly what we need in order to grow or change?” I say this all the time as a way of recognizing some mysterious connections that seem to form out of my experience, and push me where I might otherwise not go. The perfect book will come along to clarify an idea I’m grappling with. A lover will challenge me to face the shadow side of my personality, the one I was barely aware of. A comment from a friend will reveal an insensitivity I practice. Lessons abound, it seems. Eckhart Tolle says, “Life will give you whatever experience is most helpful for the evolution of your consciousness.”
But Carlson says it isn’t so much that there’s a “force” out there arranging things for my benefit as much as my own brain constructing meaning around the experiences that are before me. Our consciousness selects events, dynamics, gestures that accumulate around issues we need to address.
Whether this mysterious serendipity works from the outside or the inside, I’m grateful for it, because it happens to me a lot. And once again, I find myself beginning my response our reading this month with: The universe has brought me the very essay I needed to read today. My last writing about The Wise Heart was a long letter to two close friends, and I have not posted it out of respect for the privacy of the two recipients of the writing. Suffice it to say that Chapter 16, “Suffering and Letting Go,” was a profound chapter to me, and came to me at precisely the moment I was attempting to organize the ideas of a long and intense conversation that the three of us had had.
This week, with Chapter 17, I once again find clarity in the words of Kornfield, and solace in the face of a slightly challenging turn of events with regard to a writing that “went awry.” The substance of my writing, and the particular circumstance out of which it emerged, are not really pertinent here; rather, what interests me is the ways in which our words can miss the mark—no matter how carefully we try to compose them. It’s an old tale, of course, and anyone who takes words seriously has grappled with the challenge of expressing exactly what you think you’re trying to say. Notice all the qualifications there. It’s so damn hard to write exactly what you think you’re thinking. The avenues of error are multitudinous!
On the other hand, we also know that writing is a generative act. Most of the time, I figure out what I’m trying to say in the act of writing. So given the slipperiness of my own understanding of my words, it’s no surprise that those words would engender a number of interpretations by other readers. Books and books have been written on this topic, and I’m not really interested in exploring the communication triangle here. But when you actually experience the surprise of having your words miss their mark, the communicative act becomes intensely personal.
And then comes Kornfield and his chapter on karma, “The Compassion of the Heart: Intention and Karma.” Karma, he says, is the result of our intention. And further, he says, “The most effective way to direct our karma is to clarify our motivation and set an intention.” Intention and motivation are the roots of karma.
I read this chapter just as I was feeling anxious that my words had caused someone else pain or discomfort. This was not my intention at all! So what is a writer to do? Practice, Kornfield would say. “We must practice wise speech, non-contentiousness, generosity, and compassion over and over again, in trivial and important situations alike.” The Buddha said that practicing right speech means asking ourselves three questions: 1) Is it true? 2) Is it kind? 3) Is it necessary or useful? If you can’t say yes to all three, it might be best to refrain from speaking lest you demonstrate a lack of compassion.
When I speak to a friend, I want to speak with generosity and compassion. Knowing how to speak the truth and simultaneously encompass those qualities is a challenge to all who take up the Buddhist path. The practice that Kornfield offers at the end of this chapter is indeed a case of the universe conspiring to bring me exactly what I need at this very moment (sorry Peter Carlson!): “. . .bring the highest possible intentions to each act. Notice if they contain the elements of compassion for others and for yourself. Notice if they are wise and courageous.” Such a practice creates the karmic path upon which I walk.